High Court dismisses Mohamed’s bail challenge — he stays in custody, but can ask the magistrate again
The High Court has dismissed Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed’s challenge to the decision refusing him bail on a cybercrime charge. Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif ruled on Wednesday that Magistrate Abigail Gibbs was entitled to refuse bail, and Mohamed stays in custody at Lusignan — though he can renew his bail application before the magistrate. His remand to November 24 is unchanged.
The key points:
- Challenge dismissed — Justice Chandra-Hanif threw out the fixed-date application, filed on November 2, which asked the court to quash Magistrate Gibbs’ October 30 decision refusing Mohamed bail.
- He stays in custody — Mohamed remains at Lusignan Prison; his remand to November 24 in the cybercrime case is unchanged.
- He can ask again — the judge said he remains entitled at all times to renew his bail application before the magistrate, especially if disclosure or later developments show the risk has diminished.
- Why bail was refused — Gibbs found he was likely to commit a further offence because of a “pattern” and balanced society’s interests against his liberty. The judge said the seriousness of the alleged offence and the risk of further offending outweighed the case for bail, under the Bail Act 2022.
- Opposition Leader status counted for nothing — the court disregarded the defence argument based on his office, saying its concerns arise from the nature of the allegation, not political office.
- Defence arguments rejected — his lawyer Roysdale Forde argued seriousness was wrongly treated as a ground for refusal, the likelihood of offending was stated as a “view” without evidence, and bail conditions were never considered.
- Separate cases unchanged — the extradition first hearing is still November 23 before Chief Justice Navindra Singh, and gun-case disclosure is November 27. He is on bail in the extradition case.
- DPP strike-out bid — no new decision was reported today on the DPP’s separate bid to strike out parts of Mohamed’s affidavit.
Full story:
Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed will remain in custody after the High Court dismissed his challenge to the decision refusing him bail on a cybercrime charge.
Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif handed down the ruling on Wednesday, November 18, dismissing the fixed-date application filed on November 2, which sought an order of certiorari to quash Magistrate Abigail Gibbs’ October 30 decision. The hearing had been held on Tuesday, November 17, after several hours of submissions, and the judge had reserved her decision to Wednesday at 11:00 AM.
The challenge was brought by Mohamed’s mother, Bonita Mohamed, who argued that the magistrate’s refusal of bail should not stand.
In her ruling, Justice Chandra-Hanif said a magistrate can consider the existence, nature and relevant circumstances of pending charges when deciding whether there is a legal basis for refusing bail. The magistrate, she said, was “therefore required to assess whether the information placed before her provided a sufficiently reliable and rational foundation” for the view that releasing Mohamed on bail presented a real risk.
The judge said a judicial officer must also consider whether an accused person might interfere with a witness, influence evidence, or otherwise obstruct the proper investigation and prosecution of criminal offences. She said the administration of criminal justice depends on witnesses being able to give evidence freely and without improper influence, and that where sufficiently grounded information suggests a real risk of such interference, a magistrate may properly attach substantial weight to that concern, even at the preliminary stage — though an unsubstantiated assertion alone cannot justify refusing bail.
Gibbs had refused bail on October 30 because, in her view, Mohamed was likely to commit a further offence other than one punishable by a fine because of a “pattern”, and she balanced the interests of society against his right to personal liberty and the prejudice he would suffer in custody.
“Ultimately, after considering the relevant circumstances cumulatively, the court concluded that the concerns arising from the seriousness and gravity of the alleged offence together with the risk of further offending outweighed the considerations advanced in favour of granting bail. Consequently, bail was refused in accordance with the Bail Act 2022,” the judge said.
The court disregarded the defence’s arguments based on Mohamed being Guyana’s Opposition Leader, saying the “courts concerns arise from the nature of the allegation… and not from the accused’s political office.”
His lawyer, Roysdale Forde, had argued that seriousness was treated as a ground for refusal when the Act does not classify the offence as serious, that the likelihood of offending was stated as a “view” without evidence and inferred from other courts having granted Mohamed bail — on which no breach has been established — and that the magistrate did not weigh the matters section 7(2) of the Bail Act requires, did not consider bail conditions, and gave no reasons capable of justifying detention.
The judge left the door open for a fresh bail application. “This applicant remains entitled at all times to renew his application for bail before the magistrate as the proceedings progress, particularly where disclosure of prosecution’s evidence, subsequent developments, or other material circumstances now demonstrated that any apprehended risk may be unconfounded, diminished, or adequately addressed,” she said.
Mohamed and Police Constable Ryan Greene are charged under Section 9(2)(b) of the Cybercrime Act over the alleged unauthorised access to and transfer of police surveillance footage from the Guyana Police Force’s Safe Country system, linked to the October 12 shooting outside the Kitty home of Senior Superintendent Prem Narine, head of the Police Force’s Special Branch. On conviction on indictment, the offence carries a fine of eight million dollars and imprisonment for five years.
Mohamed remains remanded to November 24 in the cybercrime case, which is separate from the extradition proceedings against him. He is on bail in the extradition case, where the first hearing is listed for November 23 before Chief Justice Navindra Singh. He also faces three other charges — illegal possession of a firearm, illegal possession of ammunition, and attempting to obstruct the course of justice by discharging a firearm near the home of police intelligence chief Prem Narine, a witness in the extradition case — with disclosure in the gun case set for November 27.
The court had earlier struck out several disputed passages from affidavits filed in support of the challenge, News Pulse reported.
